When PW said "you're afraid to go there and ask him for more" my first reaction was "I AM NOT AFRAID TO GO THERE! SO NOT AFRAID! WHAT A DUMB STATEMENT. WHY DOES HE THINK I'M AFRAID?!?!" Definitely thought in ALL CAPS because that was the only thing that was going through my brain after such an outrageous statement. And in one sense, my reaction was correct. I am not at all afraid of getting hurt by Butterball. In spite of my fall in February, this horse feels SAFE. He shows up, he does his job as asked, and when it's a stupid ask, like a flat on your face flail from a long spot, he politely says no. Even when he gets a little squirrelly (ie when cows run at the fence behind him), he still feels safe. I think it's that he has never once checked out on me and lost his own sense of self preservation. Both thoroughbreds, at different points, checked the fuck out and went blank in the back of their eyes. Butterball? Never checked out. And he's 14.3. And in spite of his athleticism, being able to wrap my leg around his barrel makes a huge difference in how secure I feel on him.
 |
Old media, I didn't get any new this week, but leg is wrapped |
SO anyways. Not afraid of getting hurt by the horse. But when I checked back in and decided that I should try to dissect the information coming from the person I'm paying to give me information rather than just shouting internally that it wasn't true, I realized what he meant.
To make a long story long, I've spent the past week riding Butterball in his hackamore (which is a rope side pull). I started using the hackamore because I was sick of hearing him chomp chomp on the bit. So, see above about him never feeling like he's endangering me, I took away the bit.
To clarify, I don't actually hate the sound of teeth on metal. The one sound that really does that for me is anything scraping along ice. But, I hated what the sound of him chomping meant... The chomp chomp means he's not truly through and accepting contact and it means there is tension. So for a week before PW told me I was afraid, we were merrily trotting and cantering along, nose to the ground, steering off my seat and legs and somewhat adjusting pace/balance off my seat and legs. And it felt so harmonious and lovely. We even jumped things in the hackamore. Those things were small, but they came up perfectly out of stride and in a lovely forward way. Yet I could still halt in a straight line afterwards off my seat and voice. Basically, angels were singing, and I was plotting leaving the show ring forever and riding solely in his hackamore.
 |
Hackamore for the first ride at the GY's and he was perfect |
Then in the lesson, I rode him in his usual Neue Schule Turtle Top Full Cheek. He actually only chomped it twice when I bridled him, which is a definite decrease. But once I picked up contact, there it was, the familiar chomp chomp. It was during our warm up when I was "asking" for a collected canter that PW told me I was afraid. And I clued in that I am
still afraid of ruining this horse. He is, by far, the nicest horse I've ridden. He is also exquisitely sensitive and somewhat lazy. So if I let him get away with a half-assed version of what we are capable of, he is happy to deliver. But if I ask for more, but reward the tries along the way, he will deliver that too. But I have to reward the tries along the way because he is sensitive and he WANTS to be a good boy. If I don't reward the tries along the way he gets shut down and kinda turned off and dull. Whew.
PW dissected that the chomping is him not being through and then talked me through asking for more collection in the canter. When we truly got it and he lifted his forehand, the chomping stopped. Whaddya know, an initial reaction of tension and a not through attempt at slowing, but then by being gently persistent, he released the tension and actually came through. HUH. His initial reaction was one of reactance, probably that I've created, but then he came around to it. My horse and I have some things in common...
The rest of the lesson was equally interesting. Butterball's straightness fault is a left drift. I think this was there initially, but really worsened when I kept riding with my sprained ankle. This made my left leg ineffective and made me lean right pretty badly over fences to protect the ankle on landing. We're dealing with the consequences of that now.
 |
I can see the twisting/lean happening here, this was two weeks after the ankle |
 |
Corresponding view from the right side, looking at my hips they're definitely to the right |
 |
And maybe getting jumped out of the tack is actually just leaning right |
The hackamore helped to show me how inactive my left leg is compared to my right. This inactivity has allowed the left shoulders to escape. When I'm not relying on my hands, the ONLY way to fix it is by actually using my left leg. I can fix the left shoulder issue on the flat either by actually counter bending to the outside with a present, supportive left leg (funny because a bulging left shoulder while tracking left isn't actually a true counter bend, thanks brain), or by booting him off of that shoulder with my left leg at the girth to achieve true inside bend. Useful info for sure.
In the lesson, we were working through a gymnastics line of three canter poles to an oxer, one stride to a vertical, and eventually one stride to an oxer. At one point I tapped him on the left shoulder over the first fence. PW told me NO, that will chase him quick, which is not what we want once we're in the grid. Instead, he raised up the left side of the fences and added placing poles and had me aim for the right hand stripe on the poles. That finally got us straight. He also pointed out my right lean over the fence and said no matter where the horse goes, I stay in the center, but can use an open right rein to encourage him to stay right. Okay, got it. We eventually did put it together successfully and then called it a day on that.
Plenty to ponder going forward. I do think for his mental health, and mine, that some rides in the hackamore are good. It also has been very helpful for revealing holes in my position and aids. But I also tend to take it too easy on us as a team, so I'll need to structure that in a way that there are days where I put the pressure on (AND REWARD) to be better, lift more, sit more, etc.
A few other notes from the lesson that didn't fit into my story line above:
- Do not sit back and drive with the seat to go forward... close the hip angle and stay light in the seat
- When sitting the trot to fences, 90% of the weight should be in the stirrups, 10% in the seat
- Do not throw away the contact to go forward